The Destroying Angels / Blog

The fourteen years: plural marriage after the 1890 Manifesto

Of everything I read while writing this book, the fact that stopped me cold was not about money.

It was the fourteen years.

Wilford Woodruff's Manifesto came in September 1890, advising members to refrain from marriages forbidden by law. That is the date everyone knows. It is in the Doctrine and Covenants.

New plural marriages continued after it, with the knowledge of some Church leaders, principally in Mexico and Canada, until 1904.

Anthony W. Ivins, president of the Juarez Stake, performed them from 1897 to 1904 on written recommends. He kept the correspondence. Alexander F. Macdonald performed two dozen sealings in Mexico in the first half of 1890 alone, eleven of them in a single day in June.

In March 1904, testifying before the United States Senate in the Reed Smoot hearings, Church President Joseph F. Smith stated that no plural marriages had been solemnized since 1890 with the sanction, consent, or knowledge of the Church.

The Second Manifesto followed weeks later, in April 1904. Two apostles resigned in 1905.

The Church's own Gospel Topics Essay, "The Manifesto and the End of Plural Marriage," acknowledges that plural marriages continued to be performed after 1890 with the sanction of some Church leaders.

Fourteen years between the public statement and the private practice ending. That gap is where this novel lives, and it is the gap I find myself thinking about most.

Sources: the Gospel Topics Essay at churchofjesuschrist.org; D. Michael Quinn in Dialogue 18:1 (1985); Kathleen Flake, The Politics of American Religious Identity.

The novel

The Destroying Angels puts this history inside a conspiracy thriller, with a note on sources at the back that separates the documented from the invented. Read the first three chapters free.

Instant EPUB download. Also on Kindle. Discuss this piece on the Facebook page.