The Destroying Angels / Blog

Blood atonement: handling a contested doctrine honestly

A hard one, and I want to handle it carefully because it gets abused in both directions.

Brigham Young and Jedediah Grant preached blood atonement during the Reformation of 1856 and 1857. The sermons are in the Journal of Discourses, 4:49-57 and 4:219-20. They are not ambiguous about what they describe.

The Church's position is that the doctrine was never practiced and that the sermons were rhetorical, meant to shock people into repentance.

Historians disagree about how literally it was meant, and they disagree in good faith. Some of them are believing members.

I put it in the novel because it is genuinely contested, not because I think I know the answer. The chapter presents the sermons and lets the characters argue about them, which is what honest people do with contested evidence.

If your reaction is that this is anti-Mormon material: it is in the Journal of Discourses, which the Church published. That is my whole point about where this material comes from.

Source: Journal of Discourses 4:49-57 and 4:219-20.

The novel

The Destroying Angels puts this history inside a conspiracy thriller, with a note on sources at the back that separates the documented from the invented. Read the first three chapters free.

Instant EPUB download. Also on Kindle. Discuss this piece on the Facebook page.